Latest Reports and Studies

Peoples Sovereignty vs Impunity Inc.

In eight articles various cases are presened that aim to serve as tools of action for activists to use in their fight for justice against th...

The Fight Against Gold Mining in El Salvador

Article on the Chalatenango Free of Mining Campaign published in Practicing Anthropology. Read Here...

PRESS RELEASE: Mining, Corporate Social Respo…

Download the Report here (Ottawa/Washington/Melbourne)  A new study finds that OceanaGold’s attempt to rebrand its propose...

'Let Us Care for Everyone's Home': The Cathol…

A recently published essay by Phd candidate Rachel Nadelman looks at the role of the Catholic Church in the anti-mining struggle in El Salva...

  • International Allies Against Mining in El SalvadorWe are a group of organisations from Australia Canada, Europe and the U.S. that support the Salvadoran people's demand for sovereignty, the right to water and healthy communities. We coordinate our work with the National Roundtable against Metallic Mining in El Salvador and with communities directly affected by mining projects.  

    Read More
  • 1

Videos

The ICSID Rules the Pacific Rim Case will Continue

As the clock ticked towards five pm on Friday, June 1st, the International Centre for the Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID) released its ruling in the Pacific Rim vs. the Government of El Salvador case.   For background on the case see here.

The ICSID tribunal  ruled that it did not have jurisdiction under Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA) to hear the case because Pacific Rim had not been a U.S. company long enough to sue using that mechanism. However, the tribunal did consider the ICSID to have jurisdiction under Salvadoran Investment law.  Article 15 of Salvadoran Investment Law states that companies can sue the Salvadoran government through ICSID.  Therefore, the case will proceed to a third round of hearings.  

As one source analyzing the decision put it:

This was not a decision about the content of the case or the issues of mining and water contamination in El Salvador.  This was a decision on whether the tribunal set up under ICSID has jurisdiction to hear the case at all.  Pacific Rim argued that it had two different legal on-ramps to the ICSID process, one under CAFTA and the other under El Salvador investment law.  The tribunal only needed to agree with them on one to let the case move forward and they decided to make it under El Salvador investment law.  The bottom line is that the investment rules and ICSID system has once again paved the way for a foreign corporation to menace people with millions of dollars in forced payments, in this case for the sin of pressing their government to say no to a gold mining operation that will contaminate their water and threaten the health of their families.

U.S. and Canadian Organizations Respond

Public Citizen and Sierra Club responded to the decision in a press release saying “ The fact that corporate attacks on a sovereign country’s domestic environmental policy before a foreign tribunal would even be possible – much less cost a country millions when a key element of the attack is dismissed – highlights what is wrong with our ‘trade’ agreement model,” said Lori Wallach, director of Public Citizen’s Global Trade Watch. “These investor rules are an outrageous example of how ‘trade’ pacts have been stuffed with special-interest terms that empower corporate attacks on basic democratic public interest policymaking at home and abroad.”

The Institute for Policy Studies released their own statement where Director John Cavanagh said “The world should applaud the efforts of the Salvadoran people to safeguard their country’s long-term health and prosperity by becoming the first in the world to ban gold mining. Instead, this ruling is one more example of international investment rules undermining democracy in the interest of short-term profits for foreign investors.”  Spanish Version 

From Canada, Mining Watch Canada covered the decision and said "The lawsuit has been and will continue to be costly. To date, El Salvador has had to spend at least $5 million of public funds in legal fees. Five million dollars could provide one year worth of adult literacy classes for 140,000 people in El Salvador or feed 60,570 families in temporary housing for a full two weeks during a natural disaster. One would presume that the small junior mining company has paid out a similar amount and one wonders how long its few remaining shareholders will hang on for the risky ride. "

The Committee in Solidarity with the People of El Salvador published their own press release saying, “This Investment Law is just like CAFTA and other so-called free trade agreements, in that countries like El Salvador must forfeit their own democratic processes in the name of attracting foreign investment, which is a hallmark of neoliberal economic policy.” Spanish Version

Oxfam American also showed their disappointment to the ruling in their press statement, “We are very disappointed by (ICSID’s) decision to rule against El Salvador. It goes against the views the Salvadoran people who are overwhelmingly against mining,” said Keith Slack, manager of Oxfam America’s oil, gas and mining program. “We are concerned that the continued presence of Pacific Rim in El Salvador will contribute to further human rights abuses. We urge Pacific Rim not to pursue this case and to listen to the voice of the Salvadoran people.”

Response from El Salvador 

In El Salvador, the ">National Roundtable against Metallic Mining held a press conference on Friday and issued a written statement on Saturday in response to the ruling. In their statement they highlighted the need for reforms in order to protect El Salvador from these types of attacks:

"[...]President of the Republic Mauricio Funes today, in his speech after three years of government, [...] referred reforms for some laws, among them the Investment Law.  We would like to call on the government to include the elimination of Article 15 in its proposals for reforms, so as to not continue being subordinate to ICSID jurisdiction."">Video of the Mesa’s press conference regarding the Pacific Rim decision

Somewhat surprisingly, the Attorney General’s Office is construing the decision as a success.  In a post on the AG’s website, it says “It was made clear that during the preliminary stages of arbitration, Pacific Rim was incapable of refuting the evidence presented by El Salvador…”  However, after review of the document, analysts in the U.S. and El Salvador alike coincide that El Salvador actually lost on three of its four main arguments, and that while the CAFTA claim was thrown out the case will continue essentially intact. 

Press Coverage

See here for all U.S., Canadian and Salvadoran Press Coverage

The Protest in front of Pac Rim Headquarters

At about 12:30 pm on Saturday, around 200 of organizers from El Salvador, Canada, the U.S., and all over the world who were participating in the "Shout Out Against Mining Injustice" marched about 6 blocks from the "Shout Out" to PacRim headquarters in the middle of Vancouver's mining and financial center to show their opposition to the Pacific Rim case and their outrage that the ICSID ruled that it should continue. For more information see here

Recent News

Looming threats to the mining prohibition in El Salvador

Mining prohibition El Salvador - Thursday, 8 February 2018 - 07:02 AM

P. Cabezas In March 2017, El Salvador became the first country in the world to ban metallic mining. But the huge victory of the antimining movement and the international recognition it has garnered may be overshadowed by a current electoral campaign...

Lack of proposals from political candidates on the Environmental Crisis in El Sa…

Media Releases - Thursday, 8 February 2018 - 06:02 AM

PRESS RELEASE: National Roundtable Against Metallic Mining  For many years El Salvador has faced serious environmental degradation provoked in its majority by industrial processes of big corporations.  In 2018 the panorama would have been even worse, if El Salvador had given...

Long-Fought-For Ombudsperson Announced to Investigate International Complaints a…

Mining and Human Rights - Thursday, 8 February 2018 - 06:02 AM

NEWS RELEASE : January 17, 2018 (Ottawa) Today, Canada’s International Trade Minister announced the creation of a Canadian Ombudsperson for Responsible Enterprise to investigate human rights complaints about the overseas operations of Canadian companies and recommend remedy for harm done. The ombudsperson’s recommendations...

A year with a bitter taste in environmental matters in El Salvador

Mining prohibition El Salvador - Thursday, 1 February 2018 - 15:02 PM

Alfredo Carias: Vanguardia In the midst of an important victory in El Salvador, an evaluation of the social and environmental conditions in the country contrasts to the achievements obtained with the prohibition of mining. According to the Salvadoran authorities, progress has been...

National Roundtable Against Metallic Mining demands justice in the case of murde…

Pacific Rim/OceanaGold - Thursday, 1 February 2018 - 14:02 PM

Marisol Miranda: CoLatino Although there is a law against mining, fear is always present. “OceanaGold still owns the El Dorado miming project, and they are only waiting for a change of government for it to be installed again", said Domingo Miranda, at...

Can Victory Over Irresponsible Mining in Central America Spur a Win in the Phili…

Pacific Rim/OceanaGold - Thursday, 1 February 2018 - 13:02 PM

John Cavanagh, Robin Broad : RAPPLER OceanaGold was stunningly defeated in El Salvador last March. Can it be defeated in the Philippines by 2019? In March 2017, the small nation of El Salvador took a huge step towards protecting its environment for present and future generations...

Latin American Women Weaving Territories

Media Releases - Thursday, 1 February 2018 - 13:02 PM

PRESS RELEASE WOMEN OF GUATEMALA, HONDURAS AND EL SALVADOR DENOUNCE THE IMPACTS OF THE EXTRACTIVE INDUSTRIES The women of the Peaceful Resistance La Puya and the Municipality of Mataquescuintla, in Guatemala; RENACAMIH and COPINH, Honduras, ADES Santa Marta in El Salvador, and...

ICSID on the bench of the accused

Pacific Rim/OceanaGold - Wednesday, 15 November 2017 - 05:11 AM

Rufo Valencia - Radio Canada International Manuel Perez Rocha interviewed by Radio Canada International. Click here to hear the interview.  One year ago, an international coalition of civil society organizations, where Mining Watch Canada participated, released a press statement entitled: “There are no...

Mining company continues lobbying efforts to repeal Anti-Mining Law

Pacific Rim/OceanaGold - Tuesday, 14 November 2017 - 19:11 PM

Mario Beltrán - Contrapunto Environmental NGOs fear that the approaching electoral season might advance the company´s goals at the expense of the environment. Environmental organizations are worried about the promotion and education on mining that the El Dorado Foundation (face of "Corporate Social...

Collective reflections towards the UN Binding Treaty on Transnational Corporatio…

Pacific Rim/OceanaGold - Tuesday, 14 November 2017 - 19:11 PM

  CLICK HERE TO SEE THE VIDEO VIDEO: On the occasion of the third session of the UN Human Rights Council open-ended intergovernmental working group on transnational corporations (TNCs) and other business enterprises with respect to human rights (OEIGWG), the Transnational Institute, Europe-Third World...

More from this category

NOTEWORTHY

El Salvador – When The Seeds Of Resistance Bloom

Friday, June 23, 2017 - 19:06 PM

Mining prohibition El Salvador

Thomas Mc Donagh and Aldo Orellana López : The Democracy Center On 29th March 2017 legislators in El Salvador approved a blanket ban on all metal mining activities in the country – the first...

Read more

Historic Wins for Democracy and Rights in El Salvador

Monday, June 26, 2017 - 17:06 PM

Mining prohibition El Salvador

Robin Broad and John Cavanagh : Ethics and International Affairs   Recently there have been two giant wins for democracy, human rights, and the environment in an unlikely spot: the small, embattled nation...

Read more
Design: Estudio Gráfico SV | Website by Heavy Web Design