• The peaceful resistance   of la Puya in Guatemala  vs. KCA
    The peaceful resistance of la Puya in Guatemala vs. KCA

    International Allies, such as IPS, MiningWatch Canada, CIEL, and Earthworks are collaborating with other international and Guatemalan organizations to support communities peacefully resisting the ‘El Tambor’ gold mining project.  As a result of the successful resistance that led to the suspension of the project, Nevada based KCA has launched a US$300M international arbitration suit against Guatemala under the terms of the Dominican Republic-Central America Free Trade Agreement (DR-CAFTA). MORE INFO

  •  Supporting the   implementation of the   mining ban in El   Salvador
    Supporting the implementation of the mining ban in El Salvador

    We have continued to support  the activities of member organizations of the National Roundtable Against Metallic Mining, a grassroots coalition that led  a local movement to prohibit mining in March 2017. Since the mining prohibition, local organizations have continued to advocate with government authorities measures to ensure a proper implementation of the prohibition laws. The environmental movement has now formed the National Alliance against the Privatization of Water to fight attempts by the Legislative Assembly to privatice the management and distribution of water resources as the new government of president Nayib Bukele moves the country towards a more bussiness friendly environment.  MORE INFO

  • Following the tracks of   OceanaGold in the   Philippines
    Following the tracks of OceanaGold in the Philippines

    While OceanaGold has left El Salvador, the company still owns projects around the world that are facing community resistance. In nueva Vizcaya, Philippines, communities affected by the Didipio mine have been been resisting since 2007. The company has been linked to human rights violations such as failing to obtain free, prior, and informed consent (FPIC) from local indigenous communites, forced demolitions, pollution of rivers, unjust conditions of workers, illegal arrests and defamation against environmental activists and community leaders who oppose the mine. Currently,  IPS and Miningwatch Canada are supporting a coalition of communities, state government institutions and environmental organizations such as Alyansa Tigil Mina and the Kalikasan people´s Network as they fight to prevent OceanaGold from having its permit renewed. MORE INFO

  • Extraction Casino report in Colombia
    Extraction Casino report in Colombia

    In 2016, after massive protests led by the Committee in Defense of the Water and the Santurbán Highland, Colombia's Constitutional Court put the final nail in the coffin to a large gold mining project let by Canadian company Eco Oro. The court decided that no extractive activities could take place in the high-mountain ecosystems known as the ‘páramos’. As a result, Eco Oro Minerals is suing Colombian state for $764 million USD. The Comité and Colombian social organizations are now ready to mount a campaign, with international support, to dennounce the unjust lawsuit.

  • International Allies Against Mining in El SalvadorWe are a group of organisations from Australia Canada, Europe and the U.S. that support the Salvadoran people's demand for sovereignty, the right to water and healthy communities. We coordinate our work with the National Roundtable against Metallic Mining in El Salvador and with communities directly affected by mining projects.  

    Read More
  • 1

Videos

  • Up Next US Representative Ilham Omar speaks at the Letelier Moffitt Award ceremony
  • Up Next The legacy of Marcelo Rivera
  • Up Next Organizations dennounce the impact of mining in Central America
  • Up Next How El Salvador Is Creating Climate Refugees
  • Up Next Threats to the mining prohibition(SPANISH)
  • Up Next Video Conference - International Solidarity Campaign with the...
  • Up Next The Western Gazette Documentary: Mining in El Salvador
  • Up Next El Salvador prohibits Metallic Mining, A Victory for the People!
  • Up Next El Salvador Passes Historic Ban on Metal Mining
  • Up Next El Salvador's gold fight goes international
  • Up Next Unpolished Gold
    The toxic legacy of Commerce Group mining.
  • Up Next Protect Wisconsin's Water - Marc Rosenthal
  • Up Next Gold or Water?

As Salvadorans debate a mining ban due to pollution concerns, a large mining company has filed suit against the government.

by Jamie Stark*

First published in: http://www.globalpost.com/dispatches/globalpost-blogs/rights/el-salvador-gold-mining-lawsuit  

SAN SEBASTIAN, El Salvador — Vasita Escobar is certain that chemicals from the abandoned gold mine upriver from her house are slowly killing her family.

 “This company that has destroyed life, wanted to keep going,” said Escobar, in reference to Commerce Group Corp., a Wisconsin-based outfit that stopped mining for gold in San Sebastian in 2006 after permit difficulties. “My kids never get better—they’re always skinny. They always breathe the river water, they play in there. When I see my kids suffering, I know others’ are too.”

 A 2012 study confirmed Escobar’s fears: the river next to her home is contaminated with 9 times the acceptable limit of cyanide, and 1,000 times the acceptable level of iron. Cyanide is part of the chemical cocktail used on such mining sites to separate precious metals from excavated rock, and can run off into land and water.

In El Salvador as around the world, the process of digging up and crushing rock during gold mining releases naturally-occurring arsenic. But here, some of that arsenic filters through into the nearby river. When swallowed by children, it can lead to poisoning and even death.

The stakes are high: Already, only 2 percent of the country's river water is suitable for aquatic life, according to a recent study.

“That means 98 percent of the total surface water in El Salvador is contaminated,” said Pedro Cabezas, coordinator of the International Allies Against Mining in El Salvador.

Locals have taken note. More than 62 percent of Salvadorans answered “no” to a 2007 survey when asked if El Salvador is an appropriate country for metallic mining.

That opposition to mining is precisely what has gotten El Salvador into trouble: in the province of Cabañas in the country’s north, a foreign mining company is suing the republic of El Salvador, claiming the government unjustly denied a permit to open the proposed El Dorado goldmine.

The company, once called Pacific Rim but recently bought by OceanaGold, obtained the rights to explore for gold in Cabañas in 2002.

But in 2006, the government of El Salvador denied the company a permit to mine and all other administrations have continued to deny permits since. The company claims the denial is an unfair rejection of investors’ rights. Opponents say the denial was legitimate: that the company failed to complete the necessary environmental and feasibility studies required by law.

The case is being decided far from the mines: Not in El Salvador, but in Washington DC by a little-known tribunal loosely attached to the World Bank which oversees such international investment disputes.

They company, “is trying to achieve here in the World Bank what they haven’t been able to achieve in El Salvador,” says Antonio Pacheco, Executive Director and founding member of El Salvador’s Association for Economic and Social Development (ADES), which opposes the mine. Last week in Washington, Pacheco led a coalition of activists in presenting an amicus curiae brief to the World Bank tribunal, calling on it to exonerate the government.

Will the Salvadoran government be forced to pay up to $315 million in lost profits to a foreign mining company? Or will mining continue, leaving Salvadorans like Escobar in fear of the uncalculated hazards of further mining contamination?

For Salvadorans the case poses a potential lose-lose scenario: If the tribunal sides with the foreign investors, either their country goes half broke in a loss or settlement, or industrial mining continues against the popular will of a government and its citizenry. 

Polluted water, and accusations of an unspoken ban on mining

Drive the windy roads north to Victoria, a tiny pueblo repopulated by ex-guerillas from the Salvadoran Civil War, and you’ll find a quiet community with deep divisions over the mining debate. At least three murders of anti-mining activists have been attributed to the violent escalation of that debate, which pits some locals who support the mine for jobs and economic development against those who oppose it for environmental reasons.

“They have to defend the little water they have left,” said Manuel Pérez Rocha, an Associate Fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies in Washington, DC. “Their country’s hydric stress, that’s water stress, they’re very conscious that mining is very pernicious to water stability because of cyanide. The mines in Cabañas would pollute the only clean source of water the Salvadorans have.”

Although it is the smallest nation in Central America, El Salvador is rich in minerals like gold and silver. For decades, the government granted numerous permits to foreign companies to explore for buried precious metals. But beginning in 2006, under the conservative administration of President Tony Saca, the rate of granting exploitation permits suddenly dropped.

The result of fears of contamination from mining activity and years of political activism and pushback by residents is that today, El Salvador has a de facto moratorium on mining.

“There is currently no industrial gold-mining occurring in El Salvador. None,” wrote Robin Broad, a professor of International Development at American University who studies development and environmental concerns. “This is phenomenal, given the country’s relative economic poverty and the high price of gold.”

Newly elected President Salvador Sánchez Cerén has pledged to keep it that way. Preventing mining is a popular decision, but one that creates a conflict: How can a government that invited myriad mining companies to spend millions of dollars exploring for minerals now implicitly tell those companies they will never be allowed to open a mine?

Pacific Rim, the mining company suing El Salvador and recently bought by OceanaGold mining, claims that El Salvador’s denial of mining rights after granting exploratory privileges breaks the country’s commitments through the Central American Free Trade Agreement (CAFTA) and Salvadoran investment law. The mining firm is suing the Republic of El Salvador in the International Centre for Settlement of Investment Disputes (ICSID), a court loosely affiliated with the World Bank.

El Salvador argues that such a dispute should be settled in Salvadoran courts, not outside of the country.

“If it loses, the case will set a precedent allowing companies outside of DR-CAFTA to claim investor rights,” wrote James Fredrick in World Policy Review.

Those familiar with the situation whisper that the permit denial by El Salvador may have been part of a blanket and arbitrary rejection of mining permits by the Salvadoran government referred to in the industry as La Ley de la Gabeta, “The Drawer Law” — an alleged, unwritten government directive to redirect all mining proposals into the proverbial drawer where they could sit indefinitely, never to be approved. If the tribunal were to find clear evidence such a practice existed, Pacific Rim could have a strong case – such a tactic would violate basic investor rights.

El Salvador’s defense, led by Luis Parada of Foley Hoag law firm, may argue that Pacific Rim did not conduct sufficient environmental research prior to applying to dig, an accusation backed up by geologist Robert Moran, whose review of the company’s Environmental Impact Assessment, found that, “the EIA would not be acceptable in countries such as Canada or the United States.”

The three-person tribunal at the World Bank can decide: to award up to $315 million in investment losses claimed or hand over permission to mine; or rule in favor of El Salvador, leaving the international miners empty handed. This assumes the two sides do not settle before a ruling, as OceanaGold has said it would prefer.

Even if El Salvador wins the case, the country is still out the $6 million already spent on its legal defense. El Salvador can’t sue for repayment of those legal costs — Pacific Rim, the original plaintiff, was bought out by OceanaGold. 

Mining Goes Underground

While industrial mines haven’t operated here recently, the San Sebastian mine in the east has been worked continuously. Rather than multinational companies, locals dig deep, dark tunnels to excavate mineral-rich soil. They sift through the dirt to isolate small pieces of gold, which they sell through a locally organized market.

Dubbed güiriseros, these illegal miners admit to operating some 50 tunnel mines in the area of San Sebastian alone. One motley team of miners consisted of 36 men who alternate mining in two groups every other day. Although they don’t use a chemical cocktail of cyanide to get to their gold like industrial mines do, they do use mercury, which has been found in the San Sebastian river. The government looks the other way.

These güiriseros argue that they are not the biggest polluters in town. They point to the barrels of cyanide left at the top of the hill from the mining company that abandoned San Sebastian.

But some who witness this small-scale mining can envision a future in which industrial scale mining could create formal, gainful employment here in a country where a third of the population lives below the poverty line, and the GDP is $24 billion, smaller than the GDP of Vermont.

But in that respect, El Salvador’s past is rife with disappointments. Between 1904 and 1954, international mining interests dug up 32 tons of gold from the San Sebastian mine alone. Not much wealth stayed in the developing Salvadoran economy, and most of the easily accessible minerals were extracted.

The dusty tunnel miners in rural El Salvador seem far removed from the ICSID lawsuit underway in Washington. The case before the World Bank tribunal by definition focuses primarily on trade agreements and international investment, trumping local concerns or environmental factors.

The very existence of the dispute raises questions of state sovereignty in a world of free trade agreements: if a democratically elected government decides to change course on investment law after signing a free trade agreement, should they have to pay a penalty in international court?

"The threat of metal extraction is a threat to life,” Sánchez Cerén said to La Prensa Gráfica at the outset of his new term as president of El Salvador. “Everyone says that El Salvador has wealth underground, has golden valleys, basins of silver; but what does it mean if we allow it to be removed? It will destroy our lives.”

While mining and the taxes and royalties that come from it are on virtual hold in El Salvador, Cabezas estimates there are over 70 proposed mining projects just across the border.

“During the same time they’ve prevented mining in El Salvador, it’s proliferated in Guatemala and Honduras,” he said.

Sam Pazuki, communications representative for OceanaGold, declined to comment on the arbitration of the case, but said in an email that, “the company’s strong preference is to engage in a constructive dialogue with the government of El Salvador to seek a negotiated outcome to the permitting impasse.”

He added that, “It is important to note that the El Dorado Project already has very strong local community support.”

The ICSID tribunal at the World Bank will finish hearing arguments on Sept. 15, El Salvador’s Independence Day.

“On that very day,” said Pérez Rocha, “El Salvador will be defending itself at the world tribunal, defending its very rights.”

Last week in Washington, Pacheco made a plea to the United States: “I would call on the American people and the organizations in charge of this initiative to take into consideration the worries of the Salvadoran people, the farmers, the ranchers, (to understand) that they can be affected by a project like this.”

*Jacob Kushner contributed to this article.  

Recent News

The law on the right to water reaches Parliament, "people's lives are at st…

Water Crisis El Salvador - Tuesday, 15 June 2021 - 15:06 PM

FIDES Salvadoran Cardinal Gregorio Rosa Chávez, in his usual Sunday press conference, said he hopes that the initiative of the water law that the government will present contains the progress made in the proposal supported and elaborated by the Catholic Church...

First Pre-Consultation Meeting with the Xinka People on the Escobal Mine

Mining and Human Rights - Wednesday, 26 May 2021 - 10:05 AM

ResistEscobal   Indigenous Xinka authorities and the Ministry of Energy and Mines establish initial agreements regarding the pre-consultation process The first pre-consultation meeting concerning the Escobal mining license was held on Friday, May 21 of this year in the offices of the Xinka...

Pan American Silver Pressured to Shut Down Community Interference in Guatemala

Mining and Human Rights - Wednesday, 12 May 2021 - 13:05 PM

Counterpunch Jen Moore In the wake of a shooting attack, death threats, and fear of further violence against members of the peaceful resistance to Pan American Silver’s Escobal silver mine in Guatemala, nearly 4,000 people are calling on the Vancouver-based company to...

Environmental activists are being killed in Honduras over their opposition to mi…

Regional News - Thursday, 6 May 2021 - 15:05 PM

The Conversation Giada Ferrucci Two men shot Arnold Joaquín Morazán Erazo to death in his home in Tocoa, Honduras, one night in October 2020. Morazán was an environmental activist and one of 32 people criminalized by the Honduran government for defending the...

Reactivation of Cerro Blanco Mining Project

Mining and Human Rights - Thursday, 6 May 2021 - 14:05 PM

Guatemala Network Solidarity Kevo Dell In a series of tweets, in Spanish, The Extractive Industries Observatory (El Observatorio de Industrias Extractivas – OIE) has introduced a thread about the Cerro Blanco mining project in Jutiapa, and its re-opening by Bluestone Resources. The OIE...

Philippines' Duterte lifts ban on new mining deals

OceanaGold Philippines - Wednesday, 5 May 2021 - 17:05 PM

Yahoo Finance Philippine President Rodrigo Duterte officially lifted a nine-year ban on new mining projects Thursday, in a controversial move aimed at boosting state revenue and spurring investment in the country's coronavirus-devastated economy. The mining industry has stagnated since 2012 when...

A New Environmentalist Playbook An improbable victory in El Salvador offers less…

Mining prohibition El Salvador - Friday, 23 April 2021 - 01:04 AM

PROSPECT Sasha Chavkin From tropical rain forests to drinkable water, a vast share of the planet’s essential environmental resources are found in developing countries. When growth-oriented governments and powerful Western corporations set their sights on these lands, or the minerals beneath them...

Australian-Canadian mining company OceanaGold misleads public on Filipino mine

OceanaGold Philippines - Thursday, 22 April 2021 - 14:04 PM

Greenleft Ron Guy Spokesperson for the Australian National Campaign on Mining in the Philippines (ANCoMP) Andrew Morrison believes that Australian-Canadian mining company OceanaGold is misleading the public about its mine in Didipio in Central Luzon. The Philippine government said it would renew the...

‘Complete turnaround’: Philippines’ Duterte lifts ban on new mining permit…

OceanaGold Philippines - Thursday, 15 April 2021 - 01:04 AM

MONGABAY Leilani Chavez President Rodrigo Duterte has lifted a ban on issuing licenses for new mining operations in the Philippines, marking an about-face from a previous anti-mining stance that saw him ban open-pit mining in 2017 and close or suspend 26 mining...

El Salvador’s Water Defenders and the Fight Against Toxic Mining

Mining prohibition El Salvador - Sunday, 11 April 2021 - 01:04 AM

SIERRA CLUB John Gibler In 2017, El Salvador became the first country in the world to ban metal mining. Robin Broad and John Cavanagh present the story of the social struggles and legal battles behind that ban in The Water Defenders (Beacon...

NOTEWORTHY

NEW BOOK: The water defenders - how ordinary people saved a …

Thursday, January 14, 2021 - 13:01 PM

Mining prohibition El Salvador

  Water is life. Countless communities across the world, from Flint, Michigan to the Standing Rock Reservation to the Gualcarque River in Honduras, have used this phrase as a rallying cry...

Read more

From dreams of gold to organic agriculture

Tuesday, January 5, 2021 - 13:01 PM

Pacific Rim/OceanaGold

* Angélica Cárcamo / Norma Ramírez  - ARPAS In 2000, the Pacific Rim mining company intended to employ 450 families in the Department of Cabañas, north of El Salvador. Although the...

Read more